Update 02
I woke up the next morning still in between Tyler and David. I gently removed their arms so I could head out to the shower and clean up from the events of the night before. I went into the bathroom and turned on the shower. I stood under the stream quietly contemplating everything that had been happening over the weekend. I started to wash up rubbing my body wash all over. I got to my dick and found myself starting to stroke my dick. It felt so good rubbing myself imagining everything that I had done and everything I had done to me. I was broken out of my trance by the sounds of someone else walking into the bathroom. I finished up my shower and wrapped a towel around my waist before returning to my room.
I entered my room and found Tyler and David still sleeping. I unwrapped my towel and got dressed so I could go grab some breakfast. I walked over to the dining hall extremely distracted not realizing where I was walking. Then bam! I bumped into someone in front of me knocking them over. I came out of my daze and felt terrible about what happened. I noticed that it was someone smaller so I thought that they were hurt. I helped them up, apologizing about a hundred times, then I saw who it was that I ran into...it was Lexi. Now I felt really bad because I liked this girl and here I am knocking her to the ground.
"Oh my god! Lexi I am so sorry! I didn't see you, I was just lost in my thoughts and again I'm so sorry!"
"Hey Rob, it's fine! I am ok, no worries." she replied with a smile.
"Ok good. I was on my way to get some breakfast, would you like to join me?"
"Sure I would love that."
We walked into the dining hall and each grabbed a plate of food and grabbed a seat by the large windows over looking the quad. We were talking about the night before and how much fun we were having and how we'd like to do it again soon.
"Are you free tonight to come by and hang out?" I asked her with nervous anticipation.
"Yea I would love that! Do you want me to bring Mia over too? I know that Kali isn't available but Mia seemed to enjoy Tyler."
"Yea that should be fine! I will talk with him later when I get back to my room and let you know what he says."
"Awesome, can't wait."
We stayed at the table talking for what seemed like forever. Eventually, she had to go get ready for work so we hugged each other goodbye and I started back to my dorm.
I got back to my room and found that the beds were back in their original spots and everything had been cleaned up. I texted Tyler thanking him for cleaning up and told him about the girls wanting to come over if he was down. I did ask him that if he didn't want to hang out with Mia if I could have the room so I could be with Lexi. He responded back that he was down to hang out with them and mentioned that he was looking forward to spending time with Mia.
In my head I was ecstatic because not only was I going to get a chance to maybe continue what happened with Lexi the night before but that also showed me that Tyler was still interested Mia as well. A small part of me was worried that hooking up two nights in a row was going to affect our friendship.
I spent the rest of the day working on classwork while watching some football. While I was working, Tyler came back to the room and grabbed us both a drink. I had decided that working through the early game was enough so I stopped and the two of us grabbed some snacks to watch the afternoon game. While we were watching, Tyler mentioned Mia and asked me if I thought if he had a real shot with her.
"Dude she was making out with you and topless. If it wasn't for Kali getting her period she probably would have hooked up with you." I said chuckling.
He started laughing and said "yea hopefully tonight will go much better."
I texted Lexi and told her that we were all set for tonight. She replied back that she was excited and asked when to come over. I told her they could come over whenever they wanted and that we were just watching football.
They came over about 20 mins later and immediately sat down with us. They mentioned how both of them were fans of 49ers while Tyler and I were Rams fans and thats who happened to be playing at the moment. I suggested a friendly wager between the four of us. The girls agreed and asked what it should be. I initially offered if the Rams scored they would have to take a shot and if the 49ers scored we would take a shot. The girls talked quietly then Lexi got this grin on her face and said "yea that could work but how about we make it more interesting like instead of shots it's a piece of clothing." Tyler and I looked at each other and we agreed to those terms.
Sure enough as soon as we agreed, the 49ers broke off a big run and scored a touchdown.
"Of fucking course!" I yelled as the girls laughed. Tyler and I each took off our shirts as the girls were making whistling noises.
"Yea yea, you'll be the ones naked by the end of the game." I chirped back to them.
The game went back and forth with neither team scoring until the Rams picked off a pass and ran it back for a touchdown.
"Let's fucking go! Take it off ladies!"
Both of the girls made these fake angry faces and took off their tops so they were in their bras. At this point Lexi, moved closer to me and started to whisper into my ear about how much she was looking forward to hanging out. She then started to nibble on my ear which distracted me from seeing the 49ers score another touchdown.
"Take of your shorts" she whispered to me. At this point I didn't even care about the game at that point. I did as I was told and was just sitting there in my boxers sporting a semi-hard dick. I looked over and Mia was sitting on Tyler's lap and I assumed he was hard too because he was trying to shift her body weight around. I started kissing
Lexi when she again starting whispering in my ear, "I saw you guys last night..." My eyes got big and I thought I was going to die. "You guys forgot to lock the door and I came back for my phone." I was at a loss for words. I couldn't get anything to come out. "It was so hot! Maybe I could see it live tonight? Maybe Mia and I could give you guys a show." I looked her in the eyes and planted a passionate kiss on her.
As we were making out, Lexi said "sounds like the Rams scored again." At that moment both Lexi and Mia stood up and faced away from us to slowly remove their pants. Lexi was wearing a pair of black lace booty shorts to show off her ass while Mia was wearing a red thong to match hers.
Lexi walked back over to me and straddled my lap and started to grind her pussy against my cock with only the fabrics of our underwear between them. At this point, the game didn't even matter anymore, we didn't even notice that the game went to overtime. Mia chimed in and said "since it's overtime how about we raise the stakes?"
"What did you have in mind?" Tyler asked her as he was rubbing her ass.
"How about if the Rams win, Lexi and I will strip naked and make out with each other. If the 49ers win, you two strip and make out?"
Tyler was shocked by the wager and looked at me and all I could say was "yea they know. Lexi saw us last night because we forgot to lock our door."
"Ahh well in that case you're on!"
We watched with anticipation as the game clock ticked closer to :00. The 49ers marched down the field and had enough time for one last 30 yard field goal.
"Shit, that's almost a gimme" I said nervously.
"Looks like you guys better start slipping out of those boxers" Lexi said with a grin.
The four of us watched as the kicker stepped up and to make the kick. The ball sailed....wide right! The game ended in a tie!
"A tie? That wasn't part of the wager what happens now?" asked Tyler.
"We all have to get naked." Mia said as her and Lexi started to strip off their bras and panties. Here they were two gorgeous girls standing bare ass naked in front of us. Lexi had a trimmed triangular bush above her beautiful pussy while Mia was completely shaved.
"Fair is fair" I said to Tyler so the two of us stripped out of our boxers.
The girls licked their lips as they stared at our hard cocks. "So who is going to be the first pair to start us off?" I asked.
Lexi said "well since you are our hosts, you boys should go first." Tyler and I looked at each other and shrugged. We stepped up to each other I wrapped my left arm around his waist and placed my right hand behind his head. He placed his right hand behind my head and his left hand grabbed my ass. We closed our eyes and pressed our lips together allowing our tongues to slip into each others mouths and dance with one another. We continued to just sink into the kiss for a few minutes feeling our cocks rub together.
We released each other and looked over at the girls who were gently rubbing each other's bodies. "Fuck that was hot!" Mia said.
The girls interlaced their fingers while facing each other and Mia tilted her head down so Lexi could reach her. They slowly made their way closer until their lips met. We could see their tongues fighting for control in between their lips. Soon their hands let go of each other and Lexi's fingers gently slid down Mia's stomach until they reached her pussy. Mia's hands drifted up and squeezed Lexi's tits before taking her nipples in her fingers to gently pinch them. Lexi let out a soft squeal as she pressed her finger against Mia's clit. Watching this made both Tyler and me extremely horny. We reached down and began to rub each other's cocks.
We released each other as the girls made their way over to us. "As much as we want to watch you two play together, we get to play first" Lexi said as she pushed me back onto my bed. Lexi climbed up onto the bed and lowered her self onto my face so I could lick her. She tasted sweet and was already soaking wet. I sucked on her clit as she would grind her hips back and forth. I had to fight the urge to jerk my cock as much as I wanted to, I didn't want to cum just yet.
I don't know if she could sense but she turned around so we could 69. I went back to licking her pussy as she started to suck me. Lexi reached down and started to rub my balls. I thought I was gonna explode at that moment. I had to fight every fiber of my being to cum in her mouth. I needed to fuck her, to feel her wet pussy around my cock.
I tried to get her off of me so I could fuck her but despite her small frame it was like trying to move a boulder. She yelled out "no way, you're not stopping. I am going to cum and I am not getting off until I do." I said "fine, I am gonna make you cum then." At that moment, I pulled her pussy tighter to my mouth and shoved my tongue deep insider her.
"That's it don't fucking stop! Don't fucking stop!" Before I knew it a gush of warm liquid came shooting out of her pussy. I had never made a girl squirt before but it was one of the most amazing things I had every experienced.
Lexi climbed off of me and I could see that Mia was sucking Tyler's cock. I was mesmerized by it all. Lexi grabbed my face and pulled it back towards her and said "I am not done with you yet. You'll get your turn, but right now you're going to fuck me." That's all I needed to hear. I picked her up as she wrapped her legs around my waist and I threw her onto the bed. I slid my cock into her pussy and started pumping in and out.
"Fuck me you're tight. This might just be the tightest pussy I have ever fucked."
"You bet your ass it is, now shut up and fuck me!."
I did as she told and started to slam my cock into her. With her pussy feeling tighter and tighter, I could feel myself getting close to cumming. I flipped her onto her knees so I could fuck her from behind. I gave her ass a few slaps and that made her growl "harder!" This girl was insatiable. I gave my finger a lick and rubbed it on her asshole.
"Oh you dirty boy. I love it! Stick that finger in my ass"
I was in love, I had completely forgotten that we weren't alone in the room. I continued to pump into her.
"Fuck I'm getting close!"
"Give me your cum! Fill my pussy up."
"Are you sure? I never grabbed a condom"
"Don't worry about it, now cum in me!"
At that moment, I unloaded into her. We kissed some more and watched Mia riding Tyler as she also demanded that he cum in her too. I could see that Lexi was still horny as she began to rub her clit. Soon Tyler was cumming too and he also filled her pussy with his cum. Mia got off of Tyler, grabbed his hand and guided him over to my bed where he sat down next to me.
Lexi got off the bed and went over to Mia and kissed her for a bit before starting to kiss down her body. She took each nipple into her mouth one by one, then kissed down her stomach before getting on her knees to lick Mia's cum filled pussy. Mia threw her head back and moaned in pleasure. Tyler reached over to me and started to rub my cock back to life and I did the same.
He knelt over and took my cock in his mouth and started to suck my hard cock. He bobbed up and down on my dick while I continued to watch Lexi lick Mia's pussy. A few minutes later, Tyler came up and planted a kiss on me. He kissed my neck and up to my ear and whispered "you ready to fuck my ass?" I replied by standing him up, turning him around and bent him over my bed.
"Oh fuck yea" Mia said watching us getting into position. She pushed Lexi back so she could lay on the bed next to Tyler. They started to make out as I lubed his hole and slid my cock into his ass.
"Oh god that feels soooooo good" Tyler moaned out. Lexi continued eating out Mia's pussy as she reached out with her right hand and rubbed my balls. I grabbed his hips and started to pick up the pace.
"Oh fuck, oh fuck, oh fuck!" He continued to kiss Mia before telling her that my dick was filling his ass.
"It's so hot watching you getting fucked baby. That coupled with Lexi licking my pussy is going to make me cum" moaned Mia as she continued to kiss Tyler.
Mia started squealing as she came all over Lexi's face. Lexi stood up and pulled my head down so I could kiss her and taste Mia's cum on her face. She then took a finger and lubed it up before rubbing it against my asshole. She told me that she couldn't wait to watch me take Tyler's cock.
"Tyler I am gonna cum man!" I yelled out. He looked at Mia and asked her if she wanted to take my cum with him.
"Oh fuck baby that would be so hot."
The two of them got down on their knees and Lexi started jerking my cock until I shot rope after rope of cum onto both of their faces. They kissed each other and cleaned up my cum before swallowing it.
Lexi gently guided me down over the bed so I was bent over exposing my ass to Tyler. Mia laid down so Lexi and her were in a 69 with Lexi on top. Mia started licking Lexi's pussy and I started licking her ass. Tyler guided his cock into my ass which pushed my tongue deeper into Lexi's ass. Tyler was slowly pumping into my ass when Lexi told him to go faster. Tyler obliged and he started slamming into my ass.
"Oh shit man, you cock feels so good in my ass."
Hearing this coupled with be licked by both Mia and me, Lexi started to cum again.
"You going to cum in his ass baby?" Mia asked Tyler.
"You fucking better!" Both Lexi and I responded simultaneously cause the four of us to chuckle.
After a few mins of him fucking my ass, I could tell he was tensing up and getting close.
"Here it comes dude. I'm gonna cum." And with that Tyler filled my ass with his cum.
Lexi got off the bed and kneeled beneath me to lick my ass and take Tyler's cum out of my ass. Tyler and Mia had crawled into his bed and started cuddling. I got into mine when Lexi joined me and started kissing me so I could taste his cum.
"So when are we doing this again?" Lexi asked me with a smile while we laid their. Eventually we drifted off to sleep holding together. I fell asleep thinking how could I continue fooling around with both my best friend and this hottie. I needed to pick one, didn't I?
The next few days were a blur as I contemplated everything that had happened that weekend.
I had my first gay experience with my best friend, my first threesome (with all guys at that) and a hugely erotic experience of fucking one of the most beautiful girls in our drom and my best friend while also having him fuck me. If someone had asked me what I learned in my classes that week I wouldn't have been able to answer.
My mind was all over the place trying to figure out what I wanted. I knew I wanted to continue seeing Lexi but I also enjoyed fooling around with Tyler all weekend. I tried to avoid both of them as much as I could whenever I saw them trying to avoid the inevitable. Could I just see Lexi and give up what I had with Tyler which could potentially damage our friendship? Could I continue with both Tyler and Lexi knowing that she found it so hot that he and I were also fucking each other?
I knew there were times that Tyler would try and initiate a conversation in the room but I was always scared of where it was going to go so I'd make up some excuse about needing to go to the gym or the library. I could start to see that there was that same look of rejection in his eyes as that night at the concert. Was Tyler starting to feel something for me or was it again just about sex?
It was now Friday, one week after the concert. I bumped into Lexi on my way back from the gym and I apologized about avoiding her. I explained to her my conflictions and that it wasn't that I didn't like her or didn't enjoy being with her. She understood and said that she liked me too but if we wanted to just keep it casual and pressure free that we could do that. She recognized the friendship Tyler and I had and knew that this situation was unique. She told me she didn't want to cause problems for us or make things awkward but that if I ever wanted to hang out or fool around she'd be right over.
I thanked her for understanding. We gave each other a hug and a quick peck on the lips before I headed back to my room. I walked up to my door and I could hear the faint sounds of sex coming from the other side. I couldn't tell what the source was. Was Tyler watching a movie that had a sex scene or was it porn? Was he by himself or was he with someone? If he was with someone who was it? But also why did I care?
If he was alone, there was a part of me that thought about walking in and catching him. However, if he wasn't alone I didn't want to cock block him. I decided to grab some food and head over to the dining hall. I grabbed a burger and some chips before heading off and grabbing a table by the window. I slowly ate my dinner while contemplating what I wanted. I sat there for about an hour before I decided to start heading back again.
I got back to my room and pressed my ear to the door and couldn't hear anything coming from the other side. I slowly opened the door to find the room empty. I put my gym stuff down and started to get undressed so I could go get a shower when the door opened and in walked Tyler.
"Hey man where were you?" he asked.
"I was at the gym and when I came back it sounded like someone was getting some pretty good sex so I decided to go grab some dinner. So who was the lucky person?"
"There wasn't anyone in the room" he responded with a little bit of surprise in his voice.
"Dude I know what sex sounds like are and those were sex sounds."
"Oh! I was watching Game of Thrones" he laughed as he realized that the scene was loud enough that I was able to hear it in the hallway.
We both laughed about the whole situation. I told him that I was going to go take a shower when he said "I'll join you." I was confused as it was still early, he didn't mean together did he or did he just mean that he was also going to go take a shower.
"Look, Tyler, I don't know what we're doing here."
"What do you mean?"
I started to get aggravated with him. "You know what I mean. We spent 3 days last weekend fucking each other and other people including two girls that both want us. I don't know what we're doing here!"
"Is that why you've been avoiding me?"
"Yes it is. I just told Lexi that we had to keep it casual because I couldn't choose between her and potentially ruining our friendship."
"You're the one that started all this in the first place!" he shouted back at me. "You were the one that asked me to suck your dick!"
"You were the one whining about how that chick at the concert rejected you and you were saying that you wanted to try guys. I was just trying to call your bluff so you'd shut up!"
"Then why did you beg me to fuck your ass multiple times this weekend!"
"I was fucking horny! But all week I have been trying to figure out this whole goddamn situation. Lexi wants me, you're my best friend and I don't know what I want!"
"I don't know either dude! Why can't we just have fun?"
"Because we have been friends for years! Inevitably this is going to get complicated."
I grabbed my towel and shower stuff and started to walk towards the door.
"You're just going to leave?!" Tyler yelled at me.
"Yea I am going to go take a shower, showers relax me and right now I am very stressed."
"We aren't done talking about this..." Tyler reached out and grabbed my arm.
"Dude don't fucking touch me!"
"Then don't walk away from me!"
I pushed his arm hand away which caused the two of us to get very close to each other.
"I'm done! This right here is exactly why I have been avoiding you!"
I walked out the door and went to the bathroom for my shower. I turned on the shower and stood under the running water trying to calm myself down. I grabbed my body wash and started to soap up my body. I could feel myself starting to relax when I took my soapy hand and ran it around to my back and started to wash my ass. I ran my soapy finger up and down my crack until I hit my hole. The moment my finger hit my hole a jolt went through my body. I had a lot on my mind but at the center of it was Tyler. I finished up, wrapped a towel around my waist and started to leave when I bumped into Tyler. He just looked down and climbed into the stall. I went back to my room and sat down in my chair thinking about what to do next.
I don't even know how long I was sitting there when the door opened and Tyler walked in wearing only a towel. We caught each other's eyes and I was the first one to speak.
"Look, Ty, I'm sorry man. I shouldn't have gotten mad at you..."
"It's ok don't worry about it I know it's a crazy situation."
He started to walk past me when I put my arm out to stop him. I grabbed the top of his towel to loosen it so it would fall to the floor. He was standing there in front of me naked.
"Are you sure?" he asked.
I responded by reaching out stroking his cock getting it hard. I wrapped my lips around the head of his cock and started lick it. I moved back and forth along his shaft taking it deeper into my mouth. He grabbed my head the thrusted his hips forward to match the motion of my sucking.
"Oh fuck you're mouth feels so good on my dick."
I pulled back so just the head was in my mouth and I flicked my tongue over his slit.
"Oh shit don't stop!" Tyler moaned out.
"You like that? You like when I lick your cock?" I asked as I kissed the head.
"I do, I love it. If you keep going I'm going to cum."
"I want you to cum. You going to pick where you cum or am I?" I continued to lick along his shaft.
"Oh god you pick."
"Good cause I want you to cum on my face. I want you to cover me." I started to do the stroke and swirl motion on him before he moaned out that he was close.
I started to jerk his cock faster and stuck out my tongue until he shot his warm cum all over my face and tongue. I ran my fingers over my face catching it all and brought it to my lips so I could lick it off.
"That felt so good man. Why'd you do it?"
"Because I felt bad for hurting you and I wanted to make you feel better and I wanted to feel your dick in my mouth." I said with a wink.
He knelt down and kissed me while reaching down to rub my hard dick.
"So are you going to fuck my ass or no?" he whispered into my ear.
I pulled him down so he was sitting on my lap. I could feel the head of my cock pressing against his hole.
He eased himself down until all of my cock was in his ass. He then bounced himself up and down causing me to moan with pleasure.
"Fuck your ass is so tight!"
"God I love your cock in my ass!"
Tyler leaned down and kissed me. Our tongues danced with one another in our mouths.
"Carry me to your bed" he whispered. I picked him up and he wrapped his legs around my waist so my cock never left his ass. I gently placed him down and continued to kiss him. At this point it wasn't fucking anymore it was something more sensual.
I pumped my cock in and out of his ass inching closer to cumming.
"Ty, I'm so close."
"Rob please cum in my ass. I need to feel you shooting into me."
I continued to pump faster and faster.
"Oh god I'm cumming, I'm cumming!"
I unleashed my load into his ass while kissing his soft lips. When I was done, we looked into each other's eyes.
"I love you Rob."
"I love you too Ty."
"Whatever happens happens. If you want to see Lexi I won't be upset. I'll always be right here."
"Let's not worry about it now." We continued to kiss each other as I reached down to rub his cock back fo life.
"You think you can get this cock hard again?" I asked him.
"Already there babe."
I moved up so I could mount his cock. I slowly moved his cock into my ass. I bounced my ass up and down impaling myself on him. I reached back and rubbed his balls.
"Oh that feels so good."
"Good, your cock feels so good."
Tyler flipped us over so he was on top of me. He put my legs up on his shoulders so he could drive deeper into me and my own cock was staring back at me. I could feel him hitting my prostate. My cock was hard again and I started jerking myself as he continued to fuck me.
"Fuck your ass is tight. I'm going to cum!"
"Me too! Let's cum together!"
I jerked faster and faster as he picked up his pace.
"Fuck here I go!" He came into my ass and at that same moment I shot my cum all over myself hitting chest and chin.
"God that was amazing." I said as I could feel him slip his cock out.
"I could use another shower." He said with a smile and a wink.
"Me too. Let's wait a few hours though so we know people won't walk in."
We laid in bed cuddling and with Tyler's leg draped over me as he rubbed my chest. We periodically checked the clock to see if it was late enough where we could sneak over to the bathroom.
Eventually the clock read 11 pm and we figured that should he late enough. Tyler grabbed his stuff and headed over. I gave him a few minutes before I grabbed mine and walked to the bathroom. I could hear the shower on and could see his stuff next to the large hidden stall we had used the week before. I closed the stall door and unwrapped my towel. I pulled open the curtain and saw him standing their naked with the water running over his lean body. I licked my lips before I joined him running my hands all over him.
We kissed under the stream of water as we rubbed each other's cocks. Tyler got down and he held my cock until I started to piss all over him. He took a liitle in his mouth before spitting it out. He gave my cock a kiss and started to suck it. He reached behind and rubbed my hole.
"Mmmm that's it. Stick your finger in my ass."
Tyler slipped his finger in all the way to his knuckle. I was in heaven and I was getting close to cumming.
"I want your cum in my mouth" Tyler begged me with a smile on his face.
He sucked on my cock faster and faster until I shot my load down his throat. He stood up and we kissed some more.
"I have to take a leak hold on."
Tyler started to turn away from me before I stopped him. I got down on my knees in front of him and held his cock.
"I thought you weren't into this" he said with a confused look on his face.
"Yea but you're special so for you I am." I said with a smile.
I held his cock as a stream of warm piss started to flow out of his slit hitting me in the chest before it started to rise up my chin and hit me in the face. I moved my face around so he hit every centimeter of me with his piss. I was soaked in it. After he was done, I wrapped my lips around his cock and sucked him off tasting the saltiness of his piss on his slit.
Eventually he came in my mouth and I stood up so we could share his load together. We stayed in the shower getting cleaned up before we one by one went back to our room with Tyler going first.
I got back to the room and opened the door finding him on his knees on my bed.
"You ready for one more round?" he asked me.
"You bet!"
"Good now get over here and lick my hole."
I walked up behind him and shoved my tongue into his ass. Once he was good and wet I shoved my cock into his ass. I grabbed his hips and thrust as hard and as deep as I could.
"Oh fuck you cock is so deep!"
"Your ass is so tight!"
I placed one hand on his shoulder and pulled him back into me as I thrusted into him. I could feel the tip of my cock hitting his prostate.
"Dude I'm close!"
"Fill my ass with your cum!"
I shot my load deep into his ass and when I pulled out we collapsed on top of each other. We gently kissed one another until we fell asleep in each other's arms.
I entered my room and found Tyler and David still sleeping. I unwrapped my towel and got dressed so I could go grab some breakfast. I walked over to the dining hall extremely distracted not realizing where I was walking. Then bam! I bumped into someone in front of me knocking them over. I came out of my daze and felt terrible about what happened. I noticed that it was someone smaller so I thought that they were hurt. I helped them up, apologizing about a hundred times, then I saw who it was that I ran into...it was Lexi. Now I felt really bad because I liked this girl and here I am knocking her to the ground.
"Oh my god! Lexi I am so sorry! I didn't see you, I was just lost in my thoughts and again I'm so sorry!"
"Hey Rob, it's fine! I am ok, no worries." she replied with a smile.
"Ok good. I was on my way to get some breakfast, would you like to join me?"
"Sure I would love that."
We walked into the dining hall and each grabbed a plate of food and grabbed a seat by the large windows over looking the quad. We were talking about the night before and how much fun we were having and how we'd like to do it again soon.
"Are you free tonight to come by and hang out?" I asked her with nervous anticipation.
"Yea I would love that! Do you want me to bring Mia over too? I know that Kali isn't available but Mia seemed to enjoy Tyler."
"Yea that should be fine! I will talk with him later when I get back to my room and let you know what he says."
"Awesome, can't wait."
We stayed at the table talking for what seemed like forever. Eventually, she had to go get ready for work so we hugged each other goodbye and I started back to my dorm.
I got back to my room and found that the beds were back in their original spots and everything had been cleaned up. I texted Tyler thanking him for cleaning up and told him about the girls wanting to come over if he was down. I did ask him that if he didn't want to hang out with Mia if I could have the room so I could be with Lexi. He responded back that he was down to hang out with them and mentioned that he was looking forward to spending time with Mia.
In my head I was ecstatic because not only was I going to get a chance to maybe continue what happened with Lexi the night before but that also showed me that Tyler was still interested Mia as well. A small part of me was worried that hooking up two nights in a row was going to affect our friendship.
I spent the rest of the day working on classwork while watching some football. While I was working, Tyler came back to the room and grabbed us both a drink. I had decided that working through the early game was enough so I stopped and the two of us grabbed some snacks to watch the afternoon game. While we were watching, Tyler mentioned Mia and asked me if I thought if he had a real shot with her.
"Dude she was making out with you and topless. If it wasn't for Kali getting her period she probably would have hooked up with you." I said chuckling.
He started laughing and said "yea hopefully tonight will go much better."
I texted Lexi and told her that we were all set for tonight. She replied back that she was excited and asked when to come over. I told her they could come over whenever they wanted and that we were just watching football.
They came over about 20 mins later and immediately sat down with us. They mentioned how both of them were fans of 49ers while Tyler and I were Rams fans and thats who happened to be playing at the moment. I suggested a friendly wager between the four of us. The girls agreed and asked what it should be. I initially offered if the Rams scored they would have to take a shot and if the 49ers scored we would take a shot. The girls talked quietly then Lexi got this grin on her face and said "yea that could work but how about we make it more interesting like instead of shots it's a piece of clothing." Tyler and I looked at each other and we agreed to those terms.
Sure enough as soon as we agreed, the 49ers broke off a big run and scored a touchdown.
"Of fucking course!" I yelled as the girls laughed. Tyler and I each took off our shirts as the girls were making whistling noises.
"Yea yea, you'll be the ones naked by the end of the game." I chirped back to them.
The game went back and forth with neither team scoring until the Rams picked off a pass and ran it back for a touchdown.
"Let's fucking go! Take it off ladies!"
Both of the girls made these fake angry faces and took off their tops so they were in their bras. At this point Lexi, moved closer to me and started to whisper into my ear about how much she was looking forward to hanging out. She then started to nibble on my ear which distracted me from seeing the 49ers score another touchdown.
"Take of your shorts" she whispered to me. At this point I didn't even care about the game at that point. I did as I was told and was just sitting there in my boxers sporting a semi-hard dick. I looked over and Mia was sitting on Tyler's lap and I assumed he was hard too because he was trying to shift her body weight around. I started kissing
Lexi when she again starting whispering in my ear, "I saw you guys last night..." My eyes got big and I thought I was going to die. "You guys forgot to lock the door and I came back for my phone." I was at a loss for words. I couldn't get anything to come out. "It was so hot! Maybe I could see it live tonight? Maybe Mia and I could give you guys a show." I looked her in the eyes and planted a passionate kiss on her.
As we were making out, Lexi said "sounds like the Rams scored again." At that moment both Lexi and Mia stood up and faced away from us to slowly remove their pants. Lexi was wearing a pair of black lace booty shorts to show off her ass while Mia was wearing a red thong to match hers.
Lexi walked back over to me and straddled my lap and started to grind her pussy against my cock with only the fabrics of our underwear between them. At this point, the game didn't even matter anymore, we didn't even notice that the game went to overtime. Mia chimed in and said "since it's overtime how about we raise the stakes?"
"What did you have in mind?" Tyler asked her as he was rubbing her ass.
"How about if the Rams win, Lexi and I will strip naked and make out with each other. If the 49ers win, you two strip and make out?"
Tyler was shocked by the wager and looked at me and all I could say was "yea they know. Lexi saw us last night because we forgot to lock our door."
"Ahh well in that case you're on!"
We watched with anticipation as the game clock ticked closer to :00. The 49ers marched down the field and had enough time for one last 30 yard field goal.
"Shit, that's almost a gimme" I said nervously.
"Looks like you guys better start slipping out of those boxers" Lexi said with a grin.
The four of us watched as the kicker stepped up and to make the kick. The ball sailed....wide right! The game ended in a tie!
"A tie? That wasn't part of the wager what happens now?" asked Tyler.
"We all have to get naked." Mia said as her and Lexi started to strip off their bras and panties. Here they were two gorgeous girls standing bare ass naked in front of us. Lexi had a trimmed triangular bush above her beautiful pussy while Mia was completely shaved.
"Fair is fair" I said to Tyler so the two of us stripped out of our boxers.
The girls licked their lips as they stared at our hard cocks. "So who is going to be the first pair to start us off?" I asked.
Lexi said "well since you are our hosts, you boys should go first." Tyler and I looked at each other and shrugged. We stepped up to each other I wrapped my left arm around his waist and placed my right hand behind his head. He placed his right hand behind my head and his left hand grabbed my ass. We closed our eyes and pressed our lips together allowing our tongues to slip into each others mouths and dance with one another. We continued to just sink into the kiss for a few minutes feeling our cocks rub together.
We released each other and looked over at the girls who were gently rubbing each other's bodies. "Fuck that was hot!" Mia said.
The girls interlaced their fingers while facing each other and Mia tilted her head down so Lexi could reach her. They slowly made their way closer until their lips met. We could see their tongues fighting for control in between their lips. Soon their hands let go of each other and Lexi's fingers gently slid down Mia's stomach until they reached her pussy. Mia's hands drifted up and squeezed Lexi's tits before taking her nipples in her fingers to gently pinch them. Lexi let out a soft squeal as she pressed her finger against Mia's clit. Watching this made both Tyler and me extremely horny. We reached down and began to rub each other's cocks.
We released each other as the girls made their way over to us. "As much as we want to watch you two play together, we get to play first" Lexi said as she pushed me back onto my bed. Lexi climbed up onto the bed and lowered her self onto my face so I could lick her. She tasted sweet and was already soaking wet. I sucked on her clit as she would grind her hips back and forth. I had to fight the urge to jerk my cock as much as I wanted to, I didn't want to cum just yet.
I don't know if she could sense but she turned around so we could 69. I went back to licking her pussy as she started to suck me. Lexi reached down and started to rub my balls. I thought I was gonna explode at that moment. I had to fight every fiber of my being to cum in her mouth. I needed to fuck her, to feel her wet pussy around my cock.
I tried to get her off of me so I could fuck her but despite her small frame it was like trying to move a boulder. She yelled out "no way, you're not stopping. I am going to cum and I am not getting off until I do." I said "fine, I am gonna make you cum then." At that moment, I pulled her pussy tighter to my mouth and shoved my tongue deep insider her.
"That's it don't fucking stop! Don't fucking stop!" Before I knew it a gush of warm liquid came shooting out of her pussy. I had never made a girl squirt before but it was one of the most amazing things I had every experienced.
Lexi climbed off of me and I could see that Mia was sucking Tyler's cock. I was mesmerized by it all. Lexi grabbed my face and pulled it back towards her and said "I am not done with you yet. You'll get your turn, but right now you're going to fuck me." That's all I needed to hear. I picked her up as she wrapped her legs around my waist and I threw her onto the bed. I slid my cock into her pussy and started pumping in and out.
"Fuck me you're tight. This might just be the tightest pussy I have ever fucked."
"You bet your ass it is, now shut up and fuck me!."
I did as she told and started to slam my cock into her. With her pussy feeling tighter and tighter, I could feel myself getting close to cumming. I flipped her onto her knees so I could fuck her from behind. I gave her ass a few slaps and that made her growl "harder!" This girl was insatiable. I gave my finger a lick and rubbed it on her asshole.
"Oh you dirty boy. I love it! Stick that finger in my ass"
I was in love, I had completely forgotten that we weren't alone in the room. I continued to pump into her.
"Fuck I'm getting close!"
"Give me your cum! Fill my pussy up."
"Are you sure? I never grabbed a condom"
"Don't worry about it, now cum in me!"
At that moment, I unloaded into her. We kissed some more and watched Mia riding Tyler as she also demanded that he cum in her too. I could see that Lexi was still horny as she began to rub her clit. Soon Tyler was cumming too and he also filled her pussy with his cum. Mia got off of Tyler, grabbed his hand and guided him over to my bed where he sat down next to me.
Lexi got off the bed and went over to Mia and kissed her for a bit before starting to kiss down her body. She took each nipple into her mouth one by one, then kissed down her stomach before getting on her knees to lick Mia's cum filled pussy. Mia threw her head back and moaned in pleasure. Tyler reached over to me and started to rub my cock back to life and I did the same.
He knelt over and took my cock in his mouth and started to suck my hard cock. He bobbed up and down on my dick while I continued to watch Lexi lick Mia's pussy. A few minutes later, Tyler came up and planted a kiss on me. He kissed my neck and up to my ear and whispered "you ready to fuck my ass?" I replied by standing him up, turning him around and bent him over my bed.
"Oh fuck yea" Mia said watching us getting into position. She pushed Lexi back so she could lay on the bed next to Tyler. They started to make out as I lubed his hole and slid my cock into his ass.
"Oh god that feels soooooo good" Tyler moaned out. Lexi continued eating out Mia's pussy as she reached out with her right hand and rubbed my balls. I grabbed his hips and started to pick up the pace.
"Oh fuck, oh fuck, oh fuck!" He continued to kiss Mia before telling her that my dick was filling his ass.
"It's so hot watching you getting fucked baby. That coupled with Lexi licking my pussy is going to make me cum" moaned Mia as she continued to kiss Tyler.
Mia started squealing as she came all over Lexi's face. Lexi stood up and pulled my head down so I could kiss her and taste Mia's cum on her face. She then took a finger and lubed it up before rubbing it against my asshole. She told me that she couldn't wait to watch me take Tyler's cock.
"Tyler I am gonna cum man!" I yelled out. He looked at Mia and asked her if she wanted to take my cum with him.
"Oh fuck baby that would be so hot."
The two of them got down on their knees and Lexi started jerking my cock until I shot rope after rope of cum onto both of their faces. They kissed each other and cleaned up my cum before swallowing it.
Lexi gently guided me down over the bed so I was bent over exposing my ass to Tyler. Mia laid down so Lexi and her were in a 69 with Lexi on top. Mia started licking Lexi's pussy and I started licking her ass. Tyler guided his cock into my ass which pushed my tongue deeper into Lexi's ass. Tyler was slowly pumping into my ass when Lexi told him to go faster. Tyler obliged and he started slamming into my ass.
"Oh shit man, you cock feels so good in my ass."
Hearing this coupled with be licked by both Mia and me, Lexi started to cum again.
"You going to cum in his ass baby?" Mia asked Tyler.
"You fucking better!" Both Lexi and I responded simultaneously cause the four of us to chuckle.
After a few mins of him fucking my ass, I could tell he was tensing up and getting close.
"Here it comes dude. I'm gonna cum." And with that Tyler filled my ass with his cum.
Lexi got off the bed and kneeled beneath me to lick my ass and take Tyler's cum out of my ass. Tyler and Mia had crawled into his bed and started cuddling. I got into mine when Lexi joined me and started kissing me so I could taste his cum.
"So when are we doing this again?" Lexi asked me with a smile while we laid their. Eventually we drifted off to sleep holding together. I fell asleep thinking how could I continue fooling around with both my best friend and this hottie. I needed to pick one, didn't I?
The next few days were a blur as I contemplated everything that had happened that weekend.
I had my first gay experience with my best friend, my first threesome (with all guys at that) and a hugely erotic experience of fucking one of the most beautiful girls in our drom and my best friend while also having him fuck me. If someone had asked me what I learned in my classes that week I wouldn't have been able to answer.
My mind was all over the place trying to figure out what I wanted. I knew I wanted to continue seeing Lexi but I also enjoyed fooling around with Tyler all weekend. I tried to avoid both of them as much as I could whenever I saw them trying to avoid the inevitable. Could I just see Lexi and give up what I had with Tyler which could potentially damage our friendship? Could I continue with both Tyler and Lexi knowing that she found it so hot that he and I were also fucking each other?
I knew there were times that Tyler would try and initiate a conversation in the room but I was always scared of where it was going to go so I'd make up some excuse about needing to go to the gym or the library. I could start to see that there was that same look of rejection in his eyes as that night at the concert. Was Tyler starting to feel something for me or was it again just about sex?
It was now Friday, one week after the concert. I bumped into Lexi on my way back from the gym and I apologized about avoiding her. I explained to her my conflictions and that it wasn't that I didn't like her or didn't enjoy being with her. She understood and said that she liked me too but if we wanted to just keep it casual and pressure free that we could do that. She recognized the friendship Tyler and I had and knew that this situation was unique. She told me she didn't want to cause problems for us or make things awkward but that if I ever wanted to hang out or fool around she'd be right over.
I thanked her for understanding. We gave each other a hug and a quick peck on the lips before I headed back to my room. I walked up to my door and I could hear the faint sounds of sex coming from the other side. I couldn't tell what the source was. Was Tyler watching a movie that had a sex scene or was it porn? Was he by himself or was he with someone? If he was with someone who was it? But also why did I care?
If he was alone, there was a part of me that thought about walking in and catching him. However, if he wasn't alone I didn't want to cock block him. I decided to grab some food and head over to the dining hall. I grabbed a burger and some chips before heading off and grabbing a table by the window. I slowly ate my dinner while contemplating what I wanted. I sat there for about an hour before I decided to start heading back again.
I got back to my room and pressed my ear to the door and couldn't hear anything coming from the other side. I slowly opened the door to find the room empty. I put my gym stuff down and started to get undressed so I could go get a shower when the door opened and in walked Tyler.
"Hey man where were you?" he asked.
"I was at the gym and when I came back it sounded like someone was getting some pretty good sex so I decided to go grab some dinner. So who was the lucky person?"
"There wasn't anyone in the room" he responded with a little bit of surprise in his voice.
"Dude I know what sex sounds like are and those were sex sounds."
"Oh! I was watching Game of Thrones" he laughed as he realized that the scene was loud enough that I was able to hear it in the hallway.
We both laughed about the whole situation. I told him that I was going to go take a shower when he said "I'll join you." I was confused as it was still early, he didn't mean together did he or did he just mean that he was also going to go take a shower.
"Look, Tyler, I don't know what we're doing here."
"What do you mean?"
I started to get aggravated with him. "You know what I mean. We spent 3 days last weekend fucking each other and other people including two girls that both want us. I don't know what we're doing here!"
"Is that why you've been avoiding me?"
"Yes it is. I just told Lexi that we had to keep it casual because I couldn't choose between her and potentially ruining our friendship."
"You're the one that started all this in the first place!" he shouted back at me. "You were the one that asked me to suck your dick!"
"You were the one whining about how that chick at the concert rejected you and you were saying that you wanted to try guys. I was just trying to call your bluff so you'd shut up!"
"Then why did you beg me to fuck your ass multiple times this weekend!"
"I was fucking horny! But all week I have been trying to figure out this whole goddamn situation. Lexi wants me, you're my best friend and I don't know what I want!"
"I don't know either dude! Why can't we just have fun?"
"Because we have been friends for years! Inevitably this is going to get complicated."
I grabbed my towel and shower stuff and started to walk towards the door.
"You're just going to leave?!" Tyler yelled at me.
"Yea I am going to go take a shower, showers relax me and right now I am very stressed."
"We aren't done talking about this..." Tyler reached out and grabbed my arm.
"Dude don't fucking touch me!"
"Then don't walk away from me!"
I pushed his arm hand away which caused the two of us to get very close to each other.
"I'm done! This right here is exactly why I have been avoiding you!"
I walked out the door and went to the bathroom for my shower. I turned on the shower and stood under the running water trying to calm myself down. I grabbed my body wash and started to soap up my body. I could feel myself starting to relax when I took my soapy hand and ran it around to my back and started to wash my ass. I ran my soapy finger up and down my crack until I hit my hole. The moment my finger hit my hole a jolt went through my body. I had a lot on my mind but at the center of it was Tyler. I finished up, wrapped a towel around my waist and started to leave when I bumped into Tyler. He just looked down and climbed into the stall. I went back to my room and sat down in my chair thinking about what to do next.
I don't even know how long I was sitting there when the door opened and Tyler walked in wearing only a towel. We caught each other's eyes and I was the first one to speak.
"Look, Ty, I'm sorry man. I shouldn't have gotten mad at you..."
"It's ok don't worry about it I know it's a crazy situation."
He started to walk past me when I put my arm out to stop him. I grabbed the top of his towel to loosen it so it would fall to the floor. He was standing there in front of me naked.
"Are you sure?" he asked.
I responded by reaching out stroking his cock getting it hard. I wrapped my lips around the head of his cock and started lick it. I moved back and forth along his shaft taking it deeper into my mouth. He grabbed my head the thrusted his hips forward to match the motion of my sucking.
"Oh fuck you're mouth feels so good on my dick."
I pulled back so just the head was in my mouth and I flicked my tongue over his slit.
"Oh shit don't stop!" Tyler moaned out.
"You like that? You like when I lick your cock?" I asked as I kissed the head.
"I do, I love it. If you keep going I'm going to cum."
"I want you to cum. You going to pick where you cum or am I?" I continued to lick along his shaft.
"Oh god you pick."
"Good cause I want you to cum on my face. I want you to cover me." I started to do the stroke and swirl motion on him before he moaned out that he was close.
I started to jerk his cock faster and stuck out my tongue until he shot his warm cum all over my face and tongue. I ran my fingers over my face catching it all and brought it to my lips so I could lick it off.
"That felt so good man. Why'd you do it?"
"Because I felt bad for hurting you and I wanted to make you feel better and I wanted to feel your dick in my mouth." I said with a wink.
He knelt down and kissed me while reaching down to rub my hard dick.
"So are you going to fuck my ass or no?" he whispered into my ear.
I pulled him down so he was sitting on my lap. I could feel the head of my cock pressing against his hole.
He eased himself down until all of my cock was in his ass. He then bounced himself up and down causing me to moan with pleasure.
"Fuck your ass is so tight!"
"God I love your cock in my ass!"
Tyler leaned down and kissed me. Our tongues danced with one another in our mouths.
"Carry me to your bed" he whispered. I picked him up and he wrapped his legs around my waist so my cock never left his ass. I gently placed him down and continued to kiss him. At this point it wasn't fucking anymore it was something more sensual.
I pumped my cock in and out of his ass inching closer to cumming.
"Ty, I'm so close."
"Rob please cum in my ass. I need to feel you shooting into me."
I continued to pump faster and faster.
"Oh god I'm cumming, I'm cumming!"
I unleashed my load into his ass while kissing his soft lips. When I was done, we looked into each other's eyes.
"I love you Rob."
"I love you too Ty."
"Whatever happens happens. If you want to see Lexi I won't be upset. I'll always be right here."
"Let's not worry about it now." We continued to kiss each other as I reached down to rub his cock back fo life.
"You think you can get this cock hard again?" I asked him.
"Already there babe."
I moved up so I could mount his cock. I slowly moved his cock into my ass. I bounced my ass up and down impaling myself on him. I reached back and rubbed his balls.
"Oh that feels so good."
"Good, your cock feels so good."
Tyler flipped us over so he was on top of me. He put my legs up on his shoulders so he could drive deeper into me and my own cock was staring back at me. I could feel him hitting my prostate. My cock was hard again and I started jerking myself as he continued to fuck me.
"Fuck your ass is tight. I'm going to cum!"
"Me too! Let's cum together!"
I jerked faster and faster as he picked up his pace.
"Fuck here I go!" He came into my ass and at that same moment I shot my cum all over myself hitting chest and chin.
"God that was amazing." I said as I could feel him slip his cock out.
"I could use another shower." He said with a smile and a wink.
"Me too. Let's wait a few hours though so we know people won't walk in."
We laid in bed cuddling and with Tyler's leg draped over me as he rubbed my chest. We periodically checked the clock to see if it was late enough where we could sneak over to the bathroom.
Eventually the clock read 11 pm and we figured that should he late enough. Tyler grabbed his stuff and headed over. I gave him a few minutes before I grabbed mine and walked to the bathroom. I could hear the shower on and could see his stuff next to the large hidden stall we had used the week before. I closed the stall door and unwrapped my towel. I pulled open the curtain and saw him standing their naked with the water running over his lean body. I licked my lips before I joined him running my hands all over him.
We kissed under the stream of water as we rubbed each other's cocks. Tyler got down and he held my cock until I started to piss all over him. He took a liitle in his mouth before spitting it out. He gave my cock a kiss and started to suck it. He reached behind and rubbed my hole.
"Mmmm that's it. Stick your finger in my ass."
Tyler slipped his finger in all the way to his knuckle. I was in heaven and I was getting close to cumming.
"I want your cum in my mouth" Tyler begged me with a smile on his face.
He sucked on my cock faster and faster until I shot my load down his throat. He stood up and we kissed some more.
"I have to take a leak hold on."
Tyler started to turn away from me before I stopped him. I got down on my knees in front of him and held his cock.
"I thought you weren't into this" he said with a confused look on his face.
"Yea but you're special so for you I am." I said with a smile.
I held his cock as a stream of warm piss started to flow out of his slit hitting me in the chest before it started to rise up my chin and hit me in the face. I moved my face around so he hit every centimeter of me with his piss. I was soaked in it. After he was done, I wrapped my lips around his cock and sucked him off tasting the saltiness of his piss on his slit.
Eventually he came in my mouth and I stood up so we could share his load together. We stayed in the shower getting cleaned up before we one by one went back to our room with Tyler going first.
I got back to the room and opened the door finding him on his knees on my bed.
"You ready for one more round?" he asked me.
"You bet!"
"Good now get over here and lick my hole."
I walked up behind him and shoved my tongue into his ass. Once he was good and wet I shoved my cock into his ass. I grabbed his hips and thrust as hard and as deep as I could.
"Oh fuck you cock is so deep!"
"Your ass is so tight!"
I placed one hand on his shoulder and pulled him back into me as I thrusted into him. I could feel the tip of my cock hitting his prostate.
"Dude I'm close!"
"Fill my ass with your cum!"
I shot my load deep into his ass and when I pulled out we collapsed on top of each other. We gently kissed one another until we fell asleep in each other's arms.
